CupcakeCampColumbus Round Up
The third rendition of CupcakeCampColumbus (or CCC3 for short), took place in the Dispatch Kitchen at the North Market this past Sunday. I think it’s safe to say that a “sweet” time was had by all.
Our cupcake bakers went all out to compete for the prizes and the glory of being declared the champion in their category. The categories in this round tended toward the seasonal with colorful and creative cupcake entries for St. Patty’s Day, Use of Bailey’s Irish Cream or Bushmill’s Irish Whiskey and Spring Themes. The Vegan category was hugely popular (and tasty!) this round too, and the North Market Inspired cupcakes literally “took the cake” with an abundance of amazing submissions inspired by a variety of North Market merchants and their delicacies.
Let’s take a look at the categories, contestants and commentary by the judges. Judges score and/or comments in parentheses when given:
Spring Themed Entries: Judged by Olivera Bratich, Jill Moorhead and Miriam Bowers Abbott
Honeypot Lemon Thyme ~ WINNER* ~ submitted by Mandy Farnsworth (24 out of 25 points)
Hello Hummingbird ~ Honorable Mention ~submitted by Kaylon Jackson (23 out of 25 points)
Honeyed Sweet Pea~ Honorable Mention ~ submitted by Jess Lavelle (21 out of 25 points)
Buzzing Around ~ submitted by Danae Huff (20 out of 25 points)
Lovely Lavender Lemon ~ submitted by Timmura Johnson (18 out of 25 points)
The Honey Pot ~ submitted by Lisa Steward (18 out of 25 points)
Spring Garden ~ submitted by Rachel Morocco (18 out of 25 points)
*Winner Mandy Farnsworth received a CCC poster and pendant, Spinelli’s Deli gift certificate, AmyD cupcake apron, and a Scrabble Chick “Keep calm and eat a cupcake” necklace
Best Use of Bailey’s Irish Cream or Bushmills Whiskey Entries: Judged by Emily Clemons, Lisa Dillman, Johnny DiLoretto and AJ Perry
Irish Coffee ~ WINNER* ~ submitted by Christina Taylor (23 out of 25 points, adorable appearance, nice, boozy flavors & good texture)
Killarney Stout & Whiskey ~ submitted by Mandy Farnsworth (21 out of 25 points, very cute, nicely iced, nicely balanced with both whiskey and stout flavors apparent)
The Burning Bush ~ submitted by Ashley Miller (17 out of 25 points)
Irish Neopolitan ~ submitted by Mary Lynn Penner (16 out of 25 points)
Irish Devil ~ submitted by Kim Rawls (14 out of 25 points)
Tipsy Cup O’ Cake ~ submitted by Lisa Sobczynski (11 out of 25 points)
Gluten Free Bailey’s Irish Cream ~ submitted by Candace Moser Stafford (8 out of 25 points)
*Winner Christina Taylor received a CCC poster and pendant, a bottle of Bushmills Irish Whiskey (we carded her), and AmyD coffee sleeve and a Scrabble Chick “Keep calm and eat a cupcake” necklace
St. Patty’s Day Entries: Judged by Amanda Ellis, Joe Spinelli and Bethia Woolf
Irish Car Bomb A ~ WINNER* ~ submitted by Timmura Johnson (very professional looking, good flavor, creative decorations of hats and shamrocks, Bailey’s frosting, chocolate hidden in cupcake, every element added to theme)
Pot O Gold ~ Honorable Mention ~ submitted by Kaylon Jackson (loved the Cupcake Camp M&Ms and gorgeous rainbow cupcake, psychedelic! tastes like a mix)
Erin Go Bragh ~ Honorable Mention ~submitted by Erin Derryberry-Mason (great flavor & decorations, good cake, shortening frosting, sharp appearance, gold liner clever)
Pistachio Lime ~ submitted by Megan Rand (OK, good frosting, heavy, chewy)
Chocolate Stout with Irish Cream Icing ~ submitted by Chelsea Mahaffey (very gooey, good Bailey’s, not excited about appearance)
Pinch Me ~ submitted by Colleen Wingo (very lime, tart, green!)
Irish Car Bomb B ~ submitted by Christy Annis (sweet and boozy, crumbly)
Shamrock CupShake ~ submitted by MaryLynn Penner (minty, very green, a little tooth-pasty)
Shamrock Shake ~ submitted by Kate Chilek (very cute, reminds us of chewing gum or toothpaste)
*Winner Timmura Johnson received a CCC poster and pendant, an AmyD coffee sleeve, Sassafrass Bakery gift certificate and a Scrabble Chick “Keep calm and eat a cupcake” necklace
Vegan Entries: Judged by Amy Dalrymple, Jennie Scheinbach and Amy Turn-Sharp
Lemon Basil ~ WINNER* ~ submitted by Amy Hamilton (perfect! light, grown-up, good balance, moist)
Anything Goes (aka the Master and the Margarita) ~ runner up #1 ~ submitted by Stacie Sells (perfect icing, burst of freshness, lemon + salt = great mix)
Jen Surprise ~ runner up #2 ~ submitted by Jen Killius (darling, good party cupcake, great idea, kid friendly & tasty!)
Dark Chocolate Blackout ~ submitted by Jessica Kania (deep richness)
I Can’t Believe It’s Not Bacon ~ submitted by Lisa Steward (good concept)
I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butterscotch ~ submitted by Jen Uhlrich (tastes like a butterscotch lollipop)
*Winner Amy Hamilton received a CCC poster and pendant, Sweet Stella Designs cupcake bobby pins, an AmyD coffee sleeve, Bakery Gingham t-shirt and a Scrabble Chick “Keep calm and eat a cupcake” necklace
North Market Inspired Entries: Judged by Colleen Braumoeller, Bob Mangia & Martha Snee
Cardamon Sweater ~ WINNER* ~ submitted by Jim Eaton and inspired by Flavors of India (21 out of 25 points)
Hot and Cool Mango~ submitted by Sarah Loch-Test and inspired by CaJohn’s Flavor & Fire (20 out of 25 points)
Pad Thai Panache ~ submitted by Lyndsey Maynor and inspired by Nida’s Sushi (19 out of 25 points)
Earl Grey Chip ~ submitted by Lisa Sobczynski and inspired by Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams (18 out of 25 points)
Belgian Waffle Blitz ~ submitted by Lyndsey Maynor and inpired by Taste of Belgium (17 out of 25 points)
Chocolate Baklava ~ submitted by Katie Jo Kelley and inspired by Firdous Express (15 out of 25 points)
Citrus Serenade ~ submitted by Maggie Trudeau and inspired by Bubbles Tea & Juice Co. (14 out of 25 points)
The New Yorker ~ submitted by Paige DeMatteo and inspired by Barry’s New York Deli (14 out of 25 points)
Cup-a-Cannoli Cake ~ submitted by Kim Rawls and inspired by Pastaria (13 out of 25 points)
*Winner Jim Eaton received a CCC poster and pendant, Market Blooms gift certificate, AmyD coffee sleeve, Bakery Gingham t-shirt and a Scrabble Chick “Keep calm and eat a cupcake” necklace
Thanks to our discerning judges: Olivera Bratich of Wholly Craft, Colleen Braumoeller of The Greener Grocer, Miriam Bowers Abbott of The Other Paper, Emily Clemons of Surly Girl Saloon, Amy Dalrymple of Made by AmyD, Lisa Dillman of RestaurantWidow.com, Johnny DiLoretto of WSYX 6/ WTTE Fox 28, Amanda Ellis of Bakery Gingham, Bob Mangia of Market Blooms, Jill Moorhead of The Hills Market, AJ Perry of Sassafrass Bakery, Jennie Scheinback of Pattycake Vegan Bakery, Martha Snee of Omega Artisan Bakery, Joe Spinelli of Spinelli’s Deli, Amy Turn Sharp of doobleh-vay.blogspot and Bethia Woolf of HungryWoolf.com.
Proceeds from CupcakeCampColumbus will go to benefit the Mid-Ohio Food Bank. (Our accountant is tallying the amount of donation).
CupcakeCampColumbus was sponsored by Surly Girl Saloon, 52 Weeks of Baking, North Market, CrimsonCup Coffee, Bailey’s Irish Cream, Bushmills Irish Whiskey and Snowville Creamery. Judges and prize sponsors include AmyD, Bakery Gingham, Market Blooms, Pattycake Vegan Bakery, Sassafrass bakery, Spinelli’s Deli, Surly Girl Saloon and Wholly Craft.
Thanks to baker Amy Hamilton for letting us “borrow” her photos while we download ours!

OK, so it would be presumptuous to really “review” an event that we put on, so this is more of a summary than a ranking.
Let’s give a big “cheers!” to those vendors who ventured in from far and near to sample their piquant concoctions for you.
During the course of the day many a prize was awarded. We commenced the day with a homemade salsa contest. Sandi Kraft from Portage, Indiana took first prize with her spicy, sweet salsa. Donna Potts of Reynoldsburg claimed second place with her “poor man’s caviar with mango” salsa. Thanks to additional participants Shanda Behrens, Jessica Drusbacky, Al Goldenberg, Betty Huddleston, Bill Kraft, Tony Kosloski, Tim Nelson, Carson Quillin, Nancy Radke, Philip Radke, Steve Rosegger (with help from Albe Harlow), Senta Rousseau, Paul Waltermeyer and Todd Voss.
Chefs Ken Smith and Michael Ciotola (formerly of Luce and LaScala). Retired Chef Michael Ciotola took second and proved that his culinary skills are still sharp with his Pork, White Bean and Green Chili Soup topped with Cilantro Lime Cream. Newcomer Reymundo Rico from Café Corner in Harrison West (recently under new ownership) won the boxing robe and was declared North Market Chili Champ 2010 for his Chili Pazoli. The mixture of slow-roasted, garlic-rubbed pork, cilantro, red pepper, sea salt and pork sausage basked in a “pazoli sauce” made with guajilla and ancho chilies, roasted purple tomatoes, roasted garlic, red onions, hominy, kidney and black beans was divine. As if that was not enough the dish was served with a side cup of spicy Mexican Hot Chocolate complete with homemade marshmallows. Kathleen Day, the new owner of Café Corner is carrying on the Nowak brothers tradition of creative cuisine nicely!
Then there were the plucky participants in the Amateur Chili Cook-off. In second place was former participant (and second place winner) Everett Smith with his Steak Poblano Chili. First prize went to Valerie Belt with her “Nacho Mama’s Chili”. Her winning dish included Baltika Beer from Grapes of Mirth, Jose Madrid’s salsa verde plus CaJohn’s chop house seasoning and salsa kicker. Thanks to Bethann Cannell, Betty Huddleston, John Kark, Matt Latham, Tim Leigh (with Shawn Wilmoth), Wanda Faye Little, Rich & Cindy Terapak, Todd Voss, Donna Wenzel and Buzzy Zorich for playing along with us!
Next up we held the Amateur Hot Sauce Contest. Stephanie Wilt walked away with the main prize for her “Smoky Garlic with a Kick” sauce. And second place (and the accompanying prize) was congenially shared between David Huddleston for his “Hudd’s Fury” hot sauce and Jim Sulayman for his “Flytown Fire #1″ hot sauce. Thanks to Anand Merchant, Jonathan Passow, Alex Silbajoris and Todd Voss for their mouth-watering hot sauce entries as well.
Last, but far from least the Hot Wing Eating contest culminated the day’s events. Fifteen participants fought their way through CaJohn’s assault after assault of spicier and spicier wings and sauces. Only a few of wing gladiators bowed out and the finale was determined, after 6 previous rounds of two wings each, by a speed round of five wings fastest consumed. Jason (feel free to fill in a last name for me as note-taking was scarce at this point), a last-minute entry took home the title for this event.
CupcakeCampColumbus, will return to the North Market on Sunday, March 14 from 1 to 3 p.m. in the Dispatch Kitchen and “this time it’s frostable.” Organizers Carmen Owens of Surly Girl Saloon, Kiesha Jenkins-Duffy of the blog 52 Weeks of Baking and the North Market’s Mary Martineau are offering a festive Saint Patrick’s Day and spring-themed celebration of cupcakes.
Best North Market-Inspired: The North Market features a little of everything and so should these cupcakes. Cupcakes inspired by Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream flavors were popular in the last round. How about using one of our ethnic eateries for inspiration? With Thai, Vietnamese, Mediterranean, Belgian, Indian, Italian and even Polish cuisine on market there’s a world of inspiration here!
Best Vegan: No animal products permitted. Bring us the tastiest cupcake you can create without using milk, eggs, butter or any other animal product.
Finally, if you’re all about quantity over quality, perhaps you’d like to enter the Cupcake Crush. In this contest the first intrepid eater to finish a set amount of mini cupcakes provided by the Surly Girl Saloon will take home a special award. Registration for the Cupcake Crush will take place on the day of the event.
Spring seems so distant, but the North Market is here to help you melt away the winter blues and blahs with our 7th annual Fiery Foods Festival on Saturday, February 20th. Boasting everything from tropical entertainment to tongue-tingling foods the Fiery Foods Festival will put you in a sunny frame of mind!
preparing proficiency in our ever-popular Customer Chili Cook-off. The competition will garner the first place winner $100 and the runner up $50 in North Market gift certificates. Finally, those with iron gullets can register on the day of the event for the Hot Pepper Eating or the Wings of Fire wing eating contest. Familiarity with the term “capsaicin” should suggest that neither of these contests is for the faint of taste bud, but victors will take home a plethora of CaJohns’ products as prizes.
In its fifth year the Chef Chili Challenge pits local chefs against one another as contenders for the title “North Market Chili Champ 2010,” a special trophy and $200 in North Market gift certificates. Participating chefs (at the time of press release) include representatives of
• 9 - 11 a.m., musical entertainment by the Andrew Hartman Trio
The North Market Fiery Foods Festival on Saturday, February 20 is a free event. Festival activities will take place from 9 a.m.-4 p.m. Market hours are 8 a.m. - 5 p.m. To participate in the Salsa Contest, Hot Sauce Contest, Customer Chili Cook-off or the Chef Chili Challenge, and for more information, please call (614) 463-9664 or visit www.northmarket.com. Sign up for the Hot Pepper and Hot Wing Eating Contests will take place in the Dispatch Kitchen on the day of the event. A tasting fee of $5 enables onlookers to sample all of the chilis by both professional chefs and amateur contestants while supplies last. ###